The man shrugs. "Don't look at me. If I were you, I'd strongly suggest you to pay her."
"But then I'd lose my magical powers!" you say.
"Well, it's better than what you would have had to do. At least you've never even known you had magical powers. You can't miss something you've never had, right?" the man says.
"Yes, but I did have magical powers. Are you just going to take them and pretend I never had them?"
"Pretty much," the cat says.
You nod your head stiffly. There is only one thing to do: