Katie ran into the fog that night,
And I had no choice but follow
I ran right behind her in the park,
And he caught us in a hollow
She fell down, I tripped over her;
He caught us on the ground.
He didn't know he sliced two of us
'Cause we never made a sound
I saw him carry her away with him,
While he left me bleeding and alone
I would follow the spirit of my twin
To make her murderer atone
My identical twin would lead me
To where her poor dead body lay
Her spirit stayed here to guide me
And take her remains away.
I used my shirt to bind my wounds
And stumbled through the dark
Katie's spirit whispered Kelly, Kelly,
As she led me through the park
She led me through the streets
To the house where her body lay
I hid in a bush till he came out,
and I made the monster pay.