Protagonize, a collaborative creative writing community
  • Home
  • Sign Up!
  • Write
    • Write something new!
  • Explore

    Read

    • All works
    • Browse stories
    • Browse poetry
    • Browse exercises
    • Browse other works
    • Most recommended
    • Popular works
    • Top rated works
    • Recently updated
    • Previously featured
    • Orphaned works
    • Browse by tag
    • Surprise me!

    Authors

    • All authors
    • Most recommended
    • Most influential
    • Top rated authors
    • Recently active
    • Previously featured
    • Browse by name
    • Who's online?

    Groups

    • Group directory
    • Sponsored groups
    • Create a new group
    • The Protagonize Pub
    • New Members
    • Collaborative Corner
    • Planning & Brainstorming
    • Critiques Wanted
    • What You're Reading
    • Shameless Self Promotion
  • Activity
    • All recent activity
    • Weekly features
    • Recently recommended
    • Recent posts
    • Recent comments
    • Who's online?
  • Login |
  • Help
    • Need help?
    • Getting started
    • Frequently asked questions
    • About the site
    • Contact Protagonize
    • Suggestions & requests
    • Bug reports
    • Link badges
    • Upgrade to Plus Plus
  • RSS feed
Login or join Protagonize
Join Protagonize » Login

Protagonize lets you create, publish & share your writing,
collaborate with other authors, & connect with readers.

Groups » Critiques Wanted » Discussion » Need critiques on a fiction series! (I also give critiques!)
Critiques Wanted

Critiques Wanted

  • Overview
  • Discussion topics
  • Read
  • Activity
  • Members
1–3 of 3 comments
slg87

Need critiques on a fiction series! (I also give critiques!)

Posted by slg87 on May 29, 2012

Add reply
Share
Send to a fan or friend
slg87
slg87
posted May 29, 2012
Story link: http://www.protagonize.com/story/erythro

My novel series is a fantasy story about a war in a fictional place called Karst. You follow two different characters on opposite sides of the war in this first book. Technically the novel is complete but I am editing the whole thing so I am only posting a little bit at a time.

I have been working on this series for many years and I want to get serious about publishing it. Recently I have redone the whole first book (called Erythro, link above). Because of that I need serious critiques. Critiques helped me to realize that my original version had so many loose ends and plot holes that it was worth fixing up. I'm hoping that serious critiques will help me to make this new version better. Please be brutal! I need it!

I can also give critiques. I take everything I read seriously and I will tell you what I honestly think. I am good with grammar and such, so I can point out little errors for you. I will read anything! (I am not terribly good at poetry, but I'll give it a try.) Leave your link here and I will do my best to help you.

Anyone who critiques my stories will receive critiques in return! (For every one chapter you critique, I will critique a chapter of yours.) I would greatly appreciate anyone who is willing to stick in there for the wholes series!

Thank you in advance!
last edited May 31, 2012
1
KarmaBennett
KarmaBennett
posted June 1, 2012
I so appreciate where you're coming from. How can we convince anyone to critique the later chapters of our novels when they're just uploading a short story? I get lots of critiques on chapter one but few on the later chapters.

I love your agreement of a chapter for a chapter. I will hold you to it! Off to critique your chapter now!
slg87
slg87
posted June 2, 2012
Sounds good! I'll be there soon! :)

Back to top

About this group

Looking for a serious assessment of your work? Drop by and post it up for review and critique!

Note: Please read the group rules before posting in the discussions!

The Critiques Wanted group is aimed at authors who are looking for serious, detailed critiques and assessments of their work. If you think you've got a great piece of writing, gather up your courage and post it here for review.

If you're just looking for a quick pat on the back, or simply for someone to "read my story", this may not be the group for you. Instead, you'll be best served if you really want some solid discussion regarding what you're doing right or wrong, and how you can improve your writing, both technically and stylistically.

Not for the faint of heart! :)

Read more »

Find us online

  • prt.ag/JcN

Group members Browse all »

Group manager
Group Manager
joined group July 4, 2010

nickb

4 topics
36 comments
Newest group members
Browse all »
Moriba
BarahAlmashkor
HeatherLawson
Keira_Eater_Of_Souls
katiescarlett
RobbieFava
Firecycle
mcr111
king_valir
ivybee

Share this topic

Tweet
Share on Tumblr

Topic statistics

This topic has been viewed 31 times.

There following this topic.

Rated +1 by group members.

Group details

This is an official group. It's managed and moderated by the Protagonize staff and is open to all site members.

This is a public group. Its contents are visible to everyone and anyone can join.

This group allows mature content and may not be suitable for all readers.

Some rights reserved: Attribution, Noncommercial, Share Alike.

Taunt Media

Copyright © 2013 Taunt Media Inc. All rights reserved.
User-created content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 License, unless otherwise noted.

Follow us on Twitter Become a fan on Facebook
Tweet
  • About |
  • Blog |
  • Contact |
  • Advertise |
  • Media |
  • Privacy |
  • Terms of Use
Report details
by

Note: Only report items that you believe violate our disallowed content policy. Our administration team investigates all reports.

Your report was submitted successfully. Thanks!

A member of the Protagonize moderation team will review it shortly. If further clarification or information is required, they may contact you at the email address listed on your profile.

Submit report Close Cancel